Skip to content
Taskmaster Wiki

Transfer water from a bucket to a bottle using the contents of a bin

From Taskmaster Wiki
Transfer water from a bucket to a bottle using the contents of a bin
A blue bucket of water on top of a plinth.
ShowTaskmaster UK
SeasonNew Year's Treat V
EpisodeEpisode 1: 412 steps
Air date29 December 2024
TypeSolo Mental Physical Filmed Objective Single-brief Original
LocationTaskmaster House (UK)
SpaceThe Stage (Taskmaster UK)
Winner(s)Melanie Blatt
Points awarded12
Disqualifications2

Task brief

The task brief is laid on top of the lid of the middle of five metal buckets on the stage.

Transfer the most water from the bucket to the bottle using only the contents of one of these bins.

You may open one bin every minute, but you must use the contents of the bin you open last.

You may not touch or move the bucket or the bottle.

Most water in the bottle after five minutes wins.

Your time starts now.

Task notes

  • On the left-hand side of the stage, there is a low table with a glass bottle on it.
  • On the right-hand side of the stage, there is a coloured metal bucket containing water, on a plinth.
  • The five buckets (referred to in the task brief as ‘bins’) are lined up along the front of the stage in the garden, and they all have lids to conceal their contents.
  • The contents of bucket 1 are not revealed.
  • Bucket 2 contains a small ramekin made of ice.
  • Bucket 3 contains a teaspoon.
  • Bucket 4 contains a pair of knitted gloves.
  • Bucket 5 contains a length of thin plastic tubing, long enough to easily reach between the bucket and the bottle.
  • The set-up of the task, with the water source at a higher elevation than the destination, is clearly designed with siphon usage in mind.

Attempts

Martin regrets not using the ramekin

Contestant: Martin Lewis

Martin first looks inside the second bucket from the left, and finds the ice ramekin within, which he decides does not look like “an efficient transportation method”.

After a minute has passed, Martin looks inside the fourth bin from the left and finds the knitted gloves, which he decides to use. Soaking up water from the bucket in the gloves, he then attempts to squeeze the water into the bottle, before acknowledging that it’s “really tough to get in”, and that he would have been “better off with the ramekin”.

At one point, he checks with Alex that he is not allowed to touch the bottle, and Alex confirms that he may not touch nor move either the bottle or the bucket.

Martin persists with his technique, running back and forth between the bucket and the bottle, while losing most of the water in the gloves during each trip, until Alex blows his whistle.

After Alex consoles him that the bottle isn’t empty, Martin again laments the fact that he should have chosen to sue the ice ramekin. After leaving the scene of the task, Martin comes back around the side of the house to share with Alex that his attempt had clocked up 412 steps on his fitness tracker (thus coining the title of the episode).

In the studio, Alex reveals that Martin had gotten 314ml of water into his bottle. After David and Hannah’s disqualifications, this earns him 3 points.

David argues about movement at the atomic scale

Contestant: David James

David first looks inside the fourth bucket from the left, finding the knitted gloves within. Having misunderstood the task brief, he immediately grabs the gloves and starts using them to soak up water from the bucket, stating that “I’ve got a minute, so I might as well…” before Alex confirms with him that he has now made his choice for the whole task.

Despite immediately recognising that “this was a bad move, wasn’t it?”, David does his best with the gloves, running backwards and forwards with them and managing to drip at least some of the water into the bottle.

After a few attempts, he decides to move the table that the bottle is sitting upon closer to the bucket, reasoning in his mind that he is not directly moving the bottle itself. With the bottle now much closer to the source of the water, he is able to completely fill the bottle with time to spare, which he decides he will use to make himself a coffee.

As he leaves the scene with his mug of coffee at the end of the task, he can be heard arguing to himself that he hadn’t moved the bottle, and had “only moved the table”.

In the studio, Greg suggests that they should “talk about the concept of moving things”. When David attempts to argue that even putting water into the bottle would have caused “tiny little movements” of the bottle, Hannah asks him whether he talking about things “at the atomic scale”. Martin then chips in to add that matter is always moving, unless the temperature is absolute zero, before Hannah helpfully adds that “technically, the Earth is moving”. Greg responds to this discussion by checking whether they are suggesting that, in order for anyone to have succeeded in the task, they would have had to “broken the laws of physics”. He then rules that “We’re looking at the concept of moving in more pedestrian – or ‘normal’ – terms”.

When Alex checks with Greg on the status of David’s attempt, Greg confirms that he had moved the bottle, and was therefore disqualified, telling Alex “Don’t make me feel like I’m going mad!”.

Hannah uses the “ground-piping” technique

Contestant: Hannah Fry

Hannah first looks inside the fourth bucket from the left, and finds the knitted gloves within, which she describes as “bloody useless”.

After waiting for a minute to pass, she looks inside the fifth bucket from the left and finds the plastic tubing inside. She is clearly much more pleased with this option and, when Alex asks if she’s “going pipe?”, responds that “We’re ground-piping”.

Despite not knowing the correct term for the process of siphoning in the moment, Hannah does understand how it works, placing one end of the tube into the bucket while sucking on the other end. She appears to be able to easily fill the bottle using her siphon, sharing with Alex, as she waits for it to fill, that she has a PhD in Fluid Dynamics. When Alex then asks her what the process she is using is called, she suggests “pipes?”.

In the studio, Greg confirms with Hannah that “ground-piping isn’t a thing”. After confirming that Hannah had completely filled her bottle, Alex reveals that he needs to show Greg one more thing, which he thinks is “awful”, and which he says he thinks might lead to someone having “their professorship revoked”, prompting Greg to sarcastically question “which one of them could it be?”.

In the additional footage of Hannah’s attempt which is subsequently shown, she is seen touching the bottle multiple times as she struggles to keep the pipe inside of it, and to keep the bottle upright. In response to this reveal, Hannah quickly attempts to support David’s earlier argument that the bottle was always moving at the atomic scale.

Hannah is disqualified from the task for touching and moving the bottle.

Sue spits into the bottle

Contestant: Sue Johnston

Sue first looks inside the third bucket from the left, and finds the teaspoon within, announcing “I don’t think I’ll have that one. That could take me a long time.”

After waiting for a minute to pass, she looks inside the fifth bucket from the left and finds the plastic tubing inside, noting that it seems like quite a good option. When Alex notes her interest, she mimes sucking and blowing water through the tube, apparently remembering that the act of siphoning exists, but not being exactly sure how it works.

Sue does manage to initially set up the siphon correctly, placing one end in the bucket and sucking on the other until water starts flowing through, before placing that end in the bottle. However, the water then stops flowing, and she has to keep sucking on the tube, ending up with water in her mouth, which she then spits into the bottle.

In the studio, when Greg points out that it’s probably not permissible to spit the water into the bottle, Alex notes that “more liquid came out of Sue’s mouth than we expected”. He reveals Sue had gotten 478ml of water into her bottle which, after David and Hannah’s disqualifications, earns her 4 points.

Melanie uses the science of “suck and blow”

Contestant: Melanie Blatt

As Melanie arrives on the stage, Alex announces that they are in the garden, then points out how nice it is. Melanie agrees, and then mentions that it’s “getting a bit chilly, though”. In the studio, Greg observes to Alex that “you and Mel have entered the awkward post-kiss phase of your relationship”, before adding “Actually talking about the weather”. Alex admits that he was still flustered at that point, and Greg then suggests that Melanie was “seconds away from ghosting you at that point”.

Melanie first looks inside the fifth bucket from the left, and finds the plastic tubing within. She appears to have some understanding of how siphoning works, placing one end of the tube into the bucket before sucking on the other end, but the end in the bucket falls out before she can get the water flowing all the way through.

Since she has managed to get some water into the tube, though, she places the loose end into the bottle instead, and then attempts to blow the water into it with her mouth, which does not work as well as she’d hoped.

Melanie persists with this technique of emptying the contents of the tube into the bottle, before switching to placing both ends of the tube into the bottle.

In the studio, when Greg notes that Melanie had basically used the tube as a “vessel” to transport the water, she notes that she knew there was some science to the “suck and blow” technique, but didn’t exactly understand how it was supposed to work.

Alex reveals that Melanie had gotten 480ml of water into her bottle which, after David and Hannah’s disqualifications, earns her 5 points.

Points

Contestant Points Notes
Melanie Blatt 5
Sue Johnston 4
Martin Lewis 3
David James 0 Disqualified
Hannah Fry 0 Disqualified
A top-down view of one of the buckets, containing a pair of knitted gloves.

Similar tasks

Tags

buckets · bottles · bins · tables · plinths · water · tubes · tubing · ice · ramekins · spoons · gloves · lids · contents · transferring · moving · relocating · not touching · not moving · last · most · only