Skip to content
Taskmaster Wiki

Guess Shoe (Stormester Season 8 Episode 1)

From Taskmaster Wiki
Guess Shoe
ShowStormester
SeasonSeason 8
EpisodeEpisode 1: Witch
Air date7 June 2024
TypeSolo Mental Social Filmed Objective Single-brief Adapted
Master taskGuess Shoe
LocationStormester House (Season 8 - )
Winner(s)Carsten Eskelund
Points awarded15

Task brief

The task brief is presented on a plinth in the basement.

To Puk

Present Mark with the shoe he’s thinking about.

Ask only ‘yes’/’no’ questions, and say ‘How crazy!’ after every answer.

Fewest asked questions wins.

Your time starts now.


To Carsten

Present Mark with the shoe he’s thinking about.

Ask only ‘yes’/’no’ questions, and say ‘Well, well, that’s what I thought!’ after every answer.

Fewest asked questions wins.

Your time starts now.


To Natasha

Present Mark with the shoe he’s thinking about.

Ask only ‘yes’/’no’ questions, and say ‘No way!’ after every answer.

Fewest asked questions wins.

Your time starts now.


To Tobias

Present Mark with the shoe he’s thinking about.

Ask only ‘yes’/’no’ questions, and say ‘Okay, just one more thing!’ after every answer.

Fewest asked questions wins.

Your time starts now.


To Mathias

Present Mark with the shoe he’s thinking about.

Ask only ‘yes’/’no’ questions, and laugh with more and more enthusiasm after every answer.

Fewest asked questions wins.

Your time starts now.

Task notes

  • Arranged all around the basement, there are many pairs of shoes, in various styles.
  • The shoe Mark is thinking of is the right shoe of a pair of navy flats, with laces along the sides and a white bow on the toe, which are on display in one of the windows.

Variations

In this version of the task, there is no rule requiring that all of the other shoes should be out of sight when the correct shoe is presented.

Attempts

Carsten focuses on distance

Contestant: Carsten Eskelund

Carsten immediately wastes a question by asking Mark if he is currently thinking about a shoe.

He looks around the room, then asks if Mark is wearing the shoe in question (no), before asking if the shoe is within three metres of where they are currently standing (no). He immediately follows up by asking if the shoe is within three and a half metres of where they are standing (yes).

He unintentionally burns another question by asking Mark if he has a tape measure. Carsten is not provided with a tape measure, so he uses his next question to determine where in the room he should look. He tells Mark to turn his head to the left, then asks him if he is looking towards the shoe. Mark replies that he is, so Carsten finally moves away from the central plinth and starts looking at the shoes more closely.

Unfortunately for Carsten, he decides to start using his questions to have Mark confirm or deny whether individual pairs of shoes are the shoes in question, starting at almost the polar opposite location of where the correct shoe is, resulting in his burning through many more questions.

Carsten finally finds the correct pair of shoes, but is forced to ask one more question by holding up the incorrect shoe from the pair and asking Mark if it is the correct shoe.

In the studio, Carsten admits that he did not have a strategy until he was midway through the task, chalking up his early questions as “pure panic”.

Carsten finds the shoe after 29 questions, and wins the task.

Puk focuses on colours

Contestant: Puk Elgård

Puk begins her line of questioning by asking if the shoe is red. When Mark tells her that it is not, Puk goes around the room and removes all of the red shoes she can see.

She then asks if the shoe is black. When Mark tells her that it is not, she proceeds to remove all of the black shoes from display.

She then repeats this strategy for all the white shoes in the room.

Having eliminated roughly half of the shoes in the room, Puk begins to ask about individual pairs, to eliminate them.

She then resorts to playing a game of ‘hot or cold’, walking around the room and asking Mark if she is warm wherever she stops. This eventually leads her to the back corner of the basement where, after a few more incorrect guesses, she manages to locate the correct shoe.

Puk finds the shoe after 58 questions, and earns third place.

Natasha’s shoe-pernatural assist

Contestant: Natasha Brock

Natasha first asks if the shoe is a woman’s shoe. When Mark replies that it is, Natasha asks if the shoe has heels. If Natasha asks further questions at that point about the shoe’s style, they are not shown.

Natasha then spreads her arms to indicate one quarter of the basement – coincidentally, the area where the correct shoe is – and asks if the shoe is in that area. When Mark confirms that it is, Natasha takes stock of what shoes are around.

She asks Mark if the shoe is a flip-flop, and then asks if the correct shoe has a special marking on it. She then asks about a particular pair of shoes before remembering that she has already eliminated flip-flops.

Soon afterwards, she actually picks up the correct pair of shoes, but then replaces them, seemingly having eliminated them from consideration. However, it appears that the shoe is upset with Natasha, as while she is asking Mark about another nearby pair of shoes, the correct shoe falls off of its spot on the window sill and onto the ground just behind her, seeming to demand her attention. Unfortunately, Natasha does not take the hint, and instead replaces the shoe in the window, while commenting on the basement’s “creepy vibe”.

Eventually, Natasha asks Mark about all of the shoes in the area (except, of course, for the correct pair) and has eliminated all of them. Frustrated, she asks if there are any hidden shoes in the area, before finally picking up the correct shoe and asking Mark if it is the correct one, overjoyed to have finally completed the task.

In the studio, Lasse asks Natasha – who holds many new age beliefs - if she consults her tarot cards every morning, and if they have given her any answers (presumably about upcoming tasks). Natasha explains that she had a strict religious upbringing (she was raised Mormon), but that when she stopped believing in those doctrines, she needed “somewhere else to disavow responsibility”, and had therefore turned to more spiritual beliefs, including tarot cards. Carsten takes mock offence, complaining to Lasse that the fact that one contestant is able to see into the future renders the competition aspect of the show unfair.

Lasse challenges Natasha to prove that she can see into the future (which she at no point has ever actually claimed to do!) by telling him how many questions Mark will say that she asked. Carsten demands that Natasha prove her powers, calling her “Heks” (‘Witch’), and thus coining the episode title [this is a nickname Natasha subsequently carries with her throughout the season, and she has even launched a line of merchandise based on it]. Despite not actually claiming to be able to definitively see the future, Natasha plays the game anyways, guessing that she had asked 128 questions (which she later revises to “87 or 128”).

Mark informs her that had she recognised the shoe the first time she picked it up, she would have finished in just 12 questions and won the task. As it is, however, Natasha finds the shoe after 46 questions, and earns second place.

Tobias changes his phrase

Contestant: Tobias Dybvad

Tobias is not a fan of his assigned phrase (‘Okay, just one more thing’), and decides to change it. Initially, this change is minor, as he says “Just one more question” instead.

Tobias burns through a lot of extra questions by asking Mark unnecessary follow-up questions. For example, he asks Mark if the shoe is something he would wear, then follows up by asking if Mark would wear it to a party, then follows up again by asking if Mark would wear the shoe if no-one actually saw him wearing it.

He then starts asking about individual pairs of shoes without having narrowed down a target area of the room. During these rapid-fire questions, Tobias changes his response phrase again, transforming it into the question “Can I ask another question?”, which he starts saying before each of his actual questions. He continues his approach of asking Mark about individual pairs of shoes, only now – thanks to his new phrase – he is burning two questions every time.

Eventually, Tobias manages to pick up the correct pair of shoes, but burns two more questions asking about the incorrect shoe in the pair.

In the studio, Tobias seems to imply that he had thrown the task on purpose by asking as many questions as possible (including “Have I asked about this pair of shoes before?”), before admitting that his task performance was far from the dumbest thing he’s ever done.

Mark reveals that Tobias had asked 34 questions related to the shoes, plus an additional 29 questions through his phrase “Can I ask another question?”. As such, Tobias finds the correct shoe after 63 questions, and earns fourth place.

Mathias loses his mind

Contestant: Mathias Helt

Mathias initially asks Mark if he is thinking about a shoe with laces (yes). He starts throwing rejected shoes into a pile, to help himself keep track.

He then asks Mark if the shoe is black (no), before continuing to work his way around the room, pulling down shoes that do not meet the established criteria of being non-black shoes with laces. Unfortunately, as he does so, Mathias mixes up these criteria, and starts eliminating shoes that have laces, including the correct pair.

When he has finally finished dividing the shoes, Mathias looks at the piles and worries about why one of the piles is much larger than the other one. When Mark asks Mathias if he was following a system, Mathias admits that he had forgotten what his system was.

He starts to look through the pile of rejected shoes, but soon gives up, and decides to just start over. He asks Mark if the shoe is “a little feminine” (yes), and then asks about a specific pair.

Mathias makes his way through the reject pile of shoes, asking about individual pairs, and the edit of his attempt is largely dedicated to a montage of his laughing, which would much more accurately be described as ‘manic’, rather than the required ‘enthusiastic’.

Eventually, Mathias is left with three pairs of shoes which, thankfully, includes the correct pair – until Mathias rejects them for not being feminine.

When Mark subsequently rejects the remaining four shoes, Mathias’ laugh turns from manic to desperate, and he takes a moment to compose himself, as he admits to Mark that he feels like he’s going insane.

After working his way through more shoes – presumably from his reject pile – Mathias finally notices the correct pair of shoes, and adds them back to the consideration pile, finally guessing the correct shoe and crying out in victory.

In the studio, Mark reveals that Mathias had actually held the correct shoe five times without guessing (or even asking about) it, and that he had spent 1 hour and 16 minutes completing the task.

Mathias finds the correct shoe after 81 questions, and earns last place.

Points

Contestant Points Notes
Carsten Eskelund 5
Natasha Brock 4
Puk Elgård 3
Tobias Dybvad 2
Mathias Helt 1

Similar tasks

Tags

Taskmaster assistants · questions · shoes · asking · eliminating · finding · guessing · identifying · presenting · saying · fewest