Pinch, protect, or plunder (Taskmaster NZ Season 5 Episode 5)
| Pinch, protect, or plunder | |
|---|---|
Ben Hurley holding up a white card with the word ‘Protect’ written on it in black pen. He is on the Taskmaster studio stage. | |
| Show | Taskmaster NZ |
| Season | Season 5 |
| Episode | Episode 5: A marvellous tool |
| Air date | 20 August 2024 |
| Type | Solo Mental Social Live Objective Single-brief Original |
| Master task | Pinch, protect, or plunder |
| Location | South Pacific Pictures |
| Winner(s) | Ben Hurley |
| Points awarded | 13 |
| TMI task ID 3454 | |
This was a hometasking task.
Task brief
Pinch, protect, or plunder.
If you choose to pinch, you may pinch one point from the person you choose.
If you choose to plunder, you may plunder all the points of the person you choose.
If you choose to protect, you cannot be plundered, but you cannot protect from a pinch.
Most points wins.
Task notes
- The contestants are lined up side-by-side on stage, each standing behind a plinth, upon which there is a cloth bag with a dollar sign printed upon it, and a red drawstring.
- On the floor next to each plinth, there is a small whiteboard and a marker pen for the contestants to record their choice of action for each round.
- The game is played over three rounds, and each contestant begins the game with three orange table tennis balls in their bag (each ball representing one in-game point).
Variations
In this version of the task, the contestants must choose whether to pinch, protect, or plunder, and end up with the most balls. Points are awarded on a scale of 1 to 5, based on who has the most balls remaining.
Attempts
Everyone pinches, protects, and plunders

In the first round, Abby opts to ‘plunder’ Tom, although she writes ‘pluner’. Paul asks Tom if he has chosen to ‘protect’, but he has instead chosen to ‘plunder’ Josh, so Paul takes the three balls from Tom and gives them to Abby. Josh has chosen to ‘pinch’ from Abby, so he loses all three balls to Tom, but then wins one ball back from Abby. Ben has chosen to ‘plunder’ Tom, so he gets the three balls that Tom had plundered from Josh. Hayley has chosen to ‘protect’, so she neither gains nor loses any balls. Abby ends the round with five balls, Ben has six, Hayley has three, Josh has one, and Tom has zero.
In the second round, Ben chooses to ‘protect’ himself. Hayley chooses to ‘plunder’ Josh, who in turn decides to ‘pinch’ from Abby again. Hayley therefore gets Josh’s sole ball, which he immediately replaces with one from Abby. Tom looks ashamed, but he has chosen to ‘plunder’ Hayley, so he gets all four of her balls. Abby chooses to ‘plunder’ Ben, but as he had chosen to ‘protect’ himself, she gets nothing from him. Abby ends the round with four balls, Ben has six, Hayley has zero, Josh has one, and Tom has four.
In the third and final round, Hayley states that she’s a feminist but has chosen to ‘plunder’ Abby. Abby, in turn, chooses to ‘plunder’ Josh, so Hayley gets Abby’s four balls. Josh has again chosen to ‘pinch’ from Abby, so Paul takes Josh’s one ball and gives it to Abby, before immediately returning the ball to Josh. Ben opts to ‘pinch’ from Josh, so Paul takes the ball back from Josh again, saying “This ball is getting a lot of mileage this round”, and gives it to Ben. Tom decides to ‘pinch’ from Abby, who has no balls remaining by this point.
Abby and Josh both end the game with zero balls, and earn 1 point each. Hayley and Tom each end up with four balls, and earn 3 points each. Ben wins the game with seven balls, and earns 5 points.

Points
| Contestant | Points | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Ben Hurley | 5 | |
| Hayley Sproull | 3 | |
| Tom Sainsbury | 3 | |
| Abby Howells | 1 | |
| Tofiga Fepulea’i | 1 |

Similar tasks
- Snatch, steal, or shield — Stormester, New Year's Special, Episode 1 (45.83% similar)
- Pinch, protect, or plunder — Bäst i Test, Season 10, Episode 5 (33.33% similar)
- Throw your items into your bucket — Stormester, Season 8, Episode 2 (20% similar)
- Put all the table tennis balls back in the bag — Bäst i Test, Season 6, Episode 9 (19.05% similar)
- Guess the Taskmaster's opinions — Taskmaster NZ, Season 4, Episode 5 (17.39% similar)
- Disadvantage yourself in the next task — Stormester, Season 9, Episode 1 (17.39% similar)
Tags
balls · plinths · bags · points · table tennis balls · ping pong balls · pinching · plundering · protecting · choosing · selecting · writing · deciding · stealing · most