Skip to content
Taskmaster Wiki

Identify the contents of the pies

From Taskmaster Wiki
Identify the contents of the pies
ShowTaskmaster UK
SeasonSeries 1
EpisodeEpisode 2: The pie whisperer
Air date4 August 2015
TypeSolo Mental Filmed Objective Single-brief Original
Master taskIdentify the pie fillings
LocationTaskmaster House (UK)
SpaceThe Lab (Taskmaster UK)
Winner(s)Tim Key
Points awarded15

Task brief

The task brief is found on the table in the lab, alongside five different pies.

Identify the contents of these pies.

You may touch the pies but you may not breach their pastry.

Task notes

  • The contestants are able to write their guesses about the contents of the pies on the paper table covering.

Attempts

Frank ‘senses’ the pies

Contestant: Frank Skinner

Frank sniffs at, and inspects the bases of, several pies, and then appears to use pure guesswork to deduct their contents, under the naïve assumption that the contents are remotely typical pie fillings.

In the studio, Greg refers to Frank’s approach of trying to ‘sense’ the pies’ contents as an attempt at being ‘sort of a pie whisperer’ (thus coining the title of this episode).

Back in the lab, Frank gets to discover the contents of the pies for himself.

The one that he guessed was a steak and kidney pie actually contained a picture of the Taskmaster.

The one that he guessed contained cheese and potato actually contained steak.

The one that he guessed contained steak and onion actually contained frozen peas.

The one that he guessed would be a steak and ale pie was actually a marble pie.

In summary, he guessed all of the pies incorrectly, ironically only failing to suggest steak as a filling for the one pie that actually did contain steak (but which he guessed was a sweet potato and leek pie).

Unsurprisingly, he places last overall for the task.

Greg reveals via additional video footage that Frank was never able to determine the contents of the toothpaste pie, even after he’d opened it up, incorrectly guessing that it contained milk, yoghurt, Extra Strong Mints, or mint-flavoured Tipp-Ex correction fluid.

Josh breaches the pies

Contestant: Josh Widdicombe

Josh inspects the bottom of one of the pies and quickly deduces that they probably do not contain typical fillings.

He guesses, from how the bottom of one of the pies feels, that it contains marbles.

Upon inspecting a second pie he guesses, based on the weight and integrity of the base, that it is a normal pie of some description.

The base of the frozen pea pie falls away as he lifts it out of its tray for inspection, constituting an unintentional breach of the pastry.

He is able to somehow (presumably through a leak) taste the contents of the toothpaste pie and correctly determine its nature.

Back in the studio, he accepts that the frozen pea pie was breached, even though it was not his intention to do so.

It seems that Josh was penalised in his placement for this task for the accidental breach, as he appeared to be doing so well, but placed fourth overall.

Romesh questions the integrity of the pies

Contestant: Romesh Ranganathan

Romesh first attempts to deduce the contents of the pies through smell.

He then inspects the bottom of one of the pies and is able to see, through a small gap where the bottom of the pie was removed for filling, that it contains marbles.

He adopts a similar approach to deduce that one of the pies contains frozen peas.

Inspecting the base of a third pie, and finding that the bottom had not been removed, he determines that it is a more typical pie filling, and guesses steak and kidney.

Back in the studio, Roisin tries to make the argument that Romesh had ‘breached’ the pies with his eyes by looking through the gap in the pastry in their bases.

Tim backs her up on this, but Greg directs their attention back to further video footage for an example of a real breach.

As Romesh handles the toothpaste pie, the base drops out, clearly revealing its contents.

However, he is only able to determine the true nature of the filling by smelling it.

Back in the studio, Romesh angrily defends the event, stating that he did not personally breach the pie, and that it wasn’t his fault if the pie did not have sufficient structural integrity.

It seems that Romesh was penalised in his placement for this task for the accidental breach, as he appeared to be doing so well, but placed third overall, below Roisin.

Tim makes Alex breach the pies

Contestant: Tim Key

Tim immediately identifies that the task only specifies that he may not personally breach the pies, and asks Alex to punch the pies for him.

He is able to determine using this method that one of the pies contains a picture, and one of them contains beef.

Presumably fearing the damage that punching them might do to his hand, Alex then offers to ‘unscrew’ the top of the frozen pea and marble pies, revealing their contents.

Finally, Alex completely flattens the toothpaste pie with the palm of his hand, allowing Tim to determine its contents by sight and smell.

Back in the studio, Josh and Romesh are outraged that Tim and Roisin had breached the pies indirectly with Alex’s assistance, but Greg sees nothing wrong with their approach, in line with the wording of the task.

Tim earns first place in the task for his innovative approach.

Roisin makes Alex eat the pies

Contestant: Roisin Conaty

Like Tim, Roisin identifies that the task only forbids her from breaching the pies herself.

However, rather than just asking Alex to breach the pies for her, she sets herself the obstacle of asking him to taste them while she looks away, so that she can determine their contents through his reaction alone.

Using this method, she is able to correctly determine that one of the pies contains steak.

As Alex attempts to pick the marble pie up to take a bite, the bottom drops out, making quite a noise as the marbles fall into the pie tray.

However, she appears to miss the sound altogether.

To determine the contents, she asks Alex to communicate to her through his facial expression how he would feel if asked to eat the whole pie.

Based on his displeased expression, she jumps to the conclusion that the pie contains kidneys.

Alex takes a reluctant bite from the toothpaste pie, leaving creamy white filling around his mouth, based on which Roisin guesses that it must be a ‘milk pie’.

Back in the studio, Josh and Romesh are outraged that Roisin and Josh had breached the pies indirectly with Alex’s assistance, but Greg sees nothing wrong with their approach, in line with the wording of the task.

It appears that, despite sabotaging herself through her own made-up rules, Roisin managed to place second in this task simply because both Josh and Romesh had accidentally breached their pies.

Points

Contestant Points Notes
Tim Key 5
Roisin Conaty 4
Romesh Ranganathan 3
Josh Widdicombe 2
Frank Skinner 1

Tags

baked goods · contents · food · pastries · pastry · pies · deducing · filling · identifying · touching · accurate