Heavier or lighter? (Taskmaster UK Series 16 Episode 1)
| Heavier or lighter? | |
|---|---|
Alex Horne on the studio stage cradling a leaf-blower. He looks dramatically off to the side. | |
| Show | Taskmaster UK |
| Season | Series 16 |
| Episode | Episode 1: The natural friends |
| Air date | 21 September 2023 |
| Type | Solo Mental Live Objective Single-brief Original |
| Master task | Heavier or lighter? |
| Location | Pinewood Studios |
| Winner(s) | Julian Clary, Lucy Beaumont, Sam Campbell |
| Points awarded | 19 |
| TMI task ID 2712 | |
The last contestant (or team) standing won.
Task brief
Say whether you think the next item is heavier or lighter than the previous item.
If you are wrong, you are eliminated.
Last person standing wins.
Task notes
- The contestants are lined up, side-by-side, on stage, and there is a seesaw device on the stage in front of them.
- The seesaw has a platform on each end onto which Alex places items, and there is a pin in the middle of the seesaw which prevents it from moving until the contestants have guessed which one is heavier.
- The stage is littered with various items which are placed on either end of the seesaw.
- Some of the items are of normal and expected weights. Some - like the welly and the teddy bear - are deceptively heavy, because they have been filled with unexpected items
Attempts
Everyone estimates weights

In the first round, Julian must decide between eight toilet rolls and a large plastic duck. Julian correctly guesses that the duck is heavier, and survives.
In the second round, Lucy must decide between the large plastic duck and a real pineapple. Lucy correctly guesses that the pineapple is heavier and survives.
In the third round, Sam must decide between the pineapple and a wellington boot. He asks if he’s allowed to ask questions, and Greg rules that this is permitted. Sam decides to use his question to ask if Greg is “a child of divorce”. He then correctly guesses that the welly is heavier, and survives.
In the fourth round, Sue must decide between the wellington boot and a regular 1.5kg bag of flour. Sue incorrectly guesses that the bag of flour is heavier, and is eliminated. At Greg’s shock that a bag of flour is lighter than the welly, Alex hands the welly to Sue, who reveals that it is filled with a heavy chain. In response to this revelation, Sue calls Alex an “utter shit”.
In the fifth round, Susan must decide between the bag of flour and a hand bell. Susan incorrectly guesses that the bell is heavier, and is eliminated.
In the sixth round, Julian has to decide between the hand bell and a candelabra. Julian incorrectly guesses that the candelabra is lighter, and is eliminated.
In the seventh round, Lucy must decide between the candelabra and a teddy bear. She incorrectly guesses that the teddy bear is lighter, and is eliminated.
In the eighth and final round, Sam must decide between the teddy bear and a leaf-blower. He says that he knows everyone will call him crazy, but he guesses that they will be of exactly equal weight. Greg tells Sam to change his mind, because that’s not how the game works, so Sam guesses that the leaf-blower will be lighter. Due to some sort of equipment malfunction, the seesaw actually remains pretty level for a while, suggesting that the two items are indeed of equal weight. However, while Sam is expressing his frustration that Greg had made him change his guess, the end of the seesaw supporting the leaf-blower does begin to lower.
Sam is therefore eliminated, and earns joint first place, along with Julian and Lucy, while Sue and Susan earn joint fourth place.

Points
| Contestant | Points | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Julian Clary | 5 | |
| Lucy Beaumont | 5 | |
| Sam Campbell | 5 | |
| Sue Perkins | 2 | |
| Susan Wokoma | 2 |

Similar tasks
- Heavier or lighter? — Bäst i Test, Season 9, Episode 8 (34.29% similar)
- Heavier or lighter? — Stormester, Season 8, Episode 6 (23.68% similar)
- Throw a Finnish item as far as possible — Suurmestari, Season 3, Episode 10 (14.71% similar)
- Balance Markl on a see-saw — Taskmaster Portugal, Season 3, Episode 1 (14.29% similar)
- Will it fit through the hole? — Bäst i Test, Season 10, Episode 2 (14.29% similar)
- Throw, boot, bowl, flick, or propel an item — Taskmaster Australia, Season 1, Episode 1 (13.89% similar)
Tags
wellington boots · bells · candelabras · chains · flour · hand bells · leaf blowers · pineapples · rubber ducks · see saws · teddy bears · toilet rolls · wellies · welly · choosing · estimating · guessing · selecting · heavier · heavy · last · light · lighter