Skip to content
Taskmaster Wiki

Find out who stole the cookie

From Taskmaster Wiki
Find out who stole the cookie
ShowTaskmaster NZ
SeasonSeason 4
EpisodeEpisode 10: Where is Scorpio?
Air date12 September 2023
TypeTeam Mental Filmed Objective Single-brief Original
LocationTaskmaster NZ/AU House
Winner(s)Melanie Bracewell, Ray O'Leary
Points awarded13

Task brief

The contestants find the (damp) task brief on the table in the lab.

Who stole a cookie from the cookie jar?

You may make one accusation against one suspect.

Your accusation begins when you say the word 'j'accuse'.

Fastest correct accusation wins.

Your time starts now.

Task notes

  • Also on the table, there is an empty glass cookie jar, and a magnifying glass.
  • Paul has cookie crumbs on his bow tie, and a mouthful of cookie. He also has some chocolate chip cookies in one of his pockets, as well as a receipt from 'The Biscuit Palace' proving that he'd bought them himself.
  • On the floor of the lab, there is another receipt for a NZ$17 cocktail named Trial By Cherry, from a cocktail bar named Bar Poisson Rouge [Red Fish] (note: the cashier on the receipt is recorded as season 3 contestant Justine Smith [who just happens to have red hair, which sounds like 'red herring']).
  • The bar in the Taskmaster house has been dressed to play the part of Bar Poisson Rouge, where the contestants may find a half empty cocktail glass along with a red earring [sounds like 'red herring'], and a napkin upon which there is a lipstick mark and the text "Scarlett Wigs 022-035-4306" [scarlet wig = red hairpiece, sounding a little like 'red herring'?].
  • If the contestants call the number on the napkin, a phone rings inside a purse in one of the contestants' lockers. Inside the purse, there is also a note which says "Go back one tife. Guilty Man Carmine Audiology - hearing." [going back one letter on each of the letters of 'tife' turns it into the word 'shed'; the guilty man would be the culprit, carmine is a red pigment, and audiology relates to hearing (which sounds like 'herring')] and also a key.
  • There is also a cookie with a bite taken out of it inside one of the other contestants' lockers.
  • On the desk in the study, there is a document titled 'SECRETS' which otherwise appears to be completely blank.
  • The contestants may also find a note which reads "Thanks for buying my book. I know you're gonna love it. - Geri Hern".
  • There is a fake book titled "The All Cookie Diet" written by a Dr Geri Hern [anagram of 'red herring'] on one of the bookshelves in the study, inside of which the contestants may find a box with a 4-digit combination lock.
  • Also in the study, there is a fishbowl with a painted sign inside it which reads 'Red Herring'.
  • In the bread bin in the kitchen, there is a locked box which requires a key, and is labelled as being "PROPERTY OF PAUL'S SECURITY SERVICES".
  • The caravan has a sign on the door which identifies it as the office of Paul's Security Services. Inside the caravan, there is a VHS cassette player and a small TV.
  • The shed is locked with a padlock which may be opened with the key from the purse.
  • Inside the shed, the usual New Zealand fish poster has been replaced with one featuring solely images of red herrings. There is also a sign reading "Finish the gardens early" and "I left you a slice in the bread bin", plus an ultra-violet torch.
  • The UV torch can be used to read the combination lock code written on the document in the study, which turns out to be '0000'.
  • Inside the box with the combination lock, there is a key with a fob on which is written "PSS" [an abbreviation of 'Paul's Security Services']. This key opens the other locked box which was found in the bread bin.
  • The contestants may find a VHS cassette inside the locked box which, when played on the VHS player in the caravan, reveals CCTV footage of an actual red herring stealing the cookie from the jar.

Attempts

Karen, Bubbah and Dai jump to conclusions

After re-reading the task brief, Karen instantly points out that Paul’s got something in his mouth and crumbs on his bow tie.

She tries opening Paul’s mouth to get a glimpse at the cookie he is eating. Dai questions whether it’s the same cookie as the one from the jar, but quickly accepts that it could be the same.

Karen and Dai seem satisfied that there are no other possible suspects, but Bubbah appears to suspect that this solution is just way too easy. However, Karen urges her team-mates to hurry up and make a decision because the task is timed, so Bubbah gives in, and they accuse Paul of the crime after just 22 seconds.

They earn just 1 point for not having investigated any of the many clues which had been prepared for them.


Mel and Ray investigate diligently

Mel finds the cocktail receipt on the floor of the lab, and then checks Paul’s pocket, where she finds the receipt from The Biscuit Palace. She concludes that Paul had bought his own cookies, some of which they then find in his pockets. Ray suggests that they check the bar, and Mel enthusiastically agrees.

In the bar, they find the half-drunk cocktail with the red earring and the napkin with the phone number on it. Ray borrows Paul’s phone and calls the number, while Mel looks in Ray’s locker, where she finds a cookie with a bite taken out of it. Ray denies any knowledge of the cookie and asks whether Paul is trying to frame him. Ray also points out that 'Poisson Rouge' is a red herring reference.

Mel heads to the study by herself and finds a fishbowl, and a piece of paper with the word ‘secrets’ on it (note: in her Twitch stream recap of this episode, she disclosed that she had also found another task brief in the study, which read: “Congratulations Mel! Don’t let Ray read this task. If he does, one hour will be added to your time.”, which explains some of her apparent bossiness towards Ray when he subsequently enters the room, as she tries to prevent him from finding this).

Ray arrives in the study with the note he’d found, written by Dr Geri Hern. Mel sends Ray downstairs while she looks for the book written by Dr Hern, which she finds on the shelf, and opens to find the box with the combination lock inside.

Ray, meanwhile, has called the number on the napkin again, and hears another phone ringing in Karen’s locker. He finds the purse containing the phone, and also the business card for ‘Guilty Man’ at ‘Carmine Audiology’.

Mel spots the ‘red herring’ sign in the fishbowl, and realises what the meaning of the ‘red earring’ was. She shakes the locked box and guesses there is a key inside, while Ray finds the key in the purse.

Mel heads to the kitchen and calls for Ray, while finding a slice of Red Velvet cake and a locked cash box labelled “Property of Paul’s Security Services” in the bread bin. Ray asks Paul if he has the key for the cash box, which Paul says he doesn’t.

Mel then sends Ray to the caravan, which he discovers is the headquarters of Paul’s Security Services. Inside the caravan, he finds the VHS player and TV.

Mel, meanwhile, tries to look in the shed but finds it’s locked. She asks Ray to try his key on it, which works. Inside the shed, they find the red herring fish poster and the note regarding the contents of the bread bin. Mel also finds a UV torch, which she uses to reveal the secret code of ‘0000’ hidden on the ‘Secrets’ paper.

She opens the locked box with the code and finds the key with the red key fob labelled ‘PSS’. She then goes to find Ray, who is wandering around aimlessly outside with the locked cashbox.

Opening the box with the new key, they find the VHS tape labelled “LAB CAM 19/2/23”. They then put the tape in the VHS player in the caravan to watch the footage of the cookie being stolen by the literal red herring, which they subsequently accuse of the crime.

Paul stops the clock, and then Paul and Mel share the cookies (which Ray can’t eat because he is vegan).

The pair of sleuths solve the crime in 17 minutes and 16 seconds, earning 5 points.


Points

Contestant Points Notes
Melanie Bracewell 5
Ray O'Leary 5
Sieni Leo’o Olo 1
Dai Henwood 1
Karen O’Leary 1


Similar tasks

Tags

TVs · UV ink · UV torches · VHS cassettes · VHS players · accusations · books · clues · cocktails · combination locks · cookies · crimes · earrings · fish · herrings · jars · keys · locked boxes · lockers · locks · magnifying glasses · napkins · padlocks · phone numbers · phones · purses · receipts · red herrings · suspects · televisions · accusing · discovering · finding · following · investigating · searching · solving · unlocking · correct · fastest