Skip to content
Taskmaster Wiki

Build the tallest lemon tower

From Taskmaster Wiki
Build the tallest lemon tower
ShowLe Maître du Jeu
SeasonSeason 3
EpisodeEpisode 1: Première Night
Air date12 September 2024
TypeSolo Mental Physical Filmed Objective Single-brief Adapted
Master taskMake the tallest lemon tower
LocationLe Maître du Jeu House (Main seasons)
Winner(s)Bianca Gervais
Points awarded16

Task brief

The task brief is laid on the table in the lab.

Make the tallest tower using only what is in the bowl.

You may wield the knife a maximum of five times.

You have 10 minutes.

Your time starts now.

Task notes

  • Also on the table, there is a kitchen knife, a cutting board, and a bowl of lemons.
  • The verb used in the task, ‘manier’, can mean ‘handle’, ‘manipulate’, or ‘wield’. This comes into play in at least one contestant’s attempt.

Variations

In this version of the task, it is not revealed if there are toothpicks hidden in any of the lemons.

Attempts

Virginie gets philosophical

Contestant: Virginie Fortin

After reading the task brief, Virginie brings up a philosophical question: would the bowl itself be considered to be in the bowl? She attempts to justify her position by claiming that it is impossible for the bowl to be considered outside of the bowl; ergo, by default, the bowl must be inside of the bowl.

Virginie then starts removing the lemons from the bowl as Antoine comments on her Neoplatonist musings. However, by the time she has emptied the bowl of lemons, she rejects her idea of using the bowl to add height to her tower, reasoning that Louis is “very Cartesian” and would punish her for her idea (in the studio, Louis actually affirms that he would have accepted the bowl as being in the bowl).

After a few unsuccessful attempts at piling her lemons together, Virginie cuts five lemons in half and then starts stacking the halves on top of each other. Right as her time is over, most of her tower falls apart.

Virginie therefore builds just a 7cm tall lemon tower, and earns joint fourth place.


Alex squeezes lemons

Contestant: Alex Perron

Alex initially ignores the knife, and starts stacking lemons in a pyramid shape. However, when it collapses while he attempts to add a third row, he picks up the knife and starts slicing.

He then goes back to his pyramid idea, using the halved lemons as a base, and eventually using all five cuts to slice single lemons in half.

After a few attempts at building up his pyramid, Alex gets the idea to squeeze the juice out of his halved lemons, to see if they will hold the uncut lemons more solidly (presumably because they would be less prone to sliding around on the table).

At some point, Alex abandons his pyramid idea and opts to stack all of his squeezed lemon halves on top of one another.

Alex builds a 24cm tall lemon tower, and earns third place.


Bianca plays lemon Jenga

Contestant: Bianca Gervais

Bianca expresses her annoyance with the ‘wielding’ rule of the task, using several lemons to illustrate to Antoine that due to their shape, each lemon would need two cuts to be structurally sound, and that she could therefore only make a tower that is three lemons tall, at best.

After thinking it over a bit, Bianca realises that while (in her mind) each lemon still requires two cuts – to remove the pointy ends – that she can actually slice three lemons with a single cut, giving her more lemons to work with.

As Bianca starts to stack her lemons, she takes time to breathe and calm herself down, noting that her shaking hands reminds her of whenever she plays Jenga.

When she runs out of sliced lemons to stack, Bianca re-reads the task and notices that the text does not dictate that the tower needs to be self-supporting.

Bianca uses her final cut to slice off the bottom of a single lemon and add it to her tower, holding everything in place with her mouth.

When Antoine asks why Bianca doesn’t just hold her tower up with her hands instead, Bianca’s tower falls over while she is attempting to answer. She quickly rebuilds her tower, adding one more lemon on top for good measure, and once again holding it upright with her mouth, but this time also stabilising it with her hands as Antoine measures it.

Bianca builds a 49cm tall lemon tower, and wins the task.


Richardson draws on past training

Contestant: Richardson Zéphir

Richardson immediately realises that he needs to be smart with his limited knife uses, and promptly lines up four lemons in a line, slicing them all apart with a single cut.

As he continues to slice through lemons, Antoine warns Richardson to be careful that he doesn’t slice his fingers. Richardson informs Antoine that he used to be a chef (he was the co-owner of a restaurant called Terrasses Bonsecours for five years).

Richardson is apparently of the same philosophical school of thought as Virginie – that the bowl is in the bowl – as he builds his lemon tower on top of the overturned bowl.

Richardson uses what is presumably his final cut to stab the knife all the way down through his lemon tower, holding everything together on top of the bowl.

Richardson builds a 31cm lemon tower – including the bowl – and earns second place.


Arnaud is foiled by the dictionary

Contestant: Arnaud Soly

Immediately after reading the task brief, Arnaud poses a hypothetical to Antoine: as long as the knife always remains in his hand, would that count as a single wield? Antoine defers the decision to the Taskmaster.

Arnaud quickly decides that his interpretation is valid, pointing out that in movies, when someone wields a sword, it’s over multiple blows and not just one – even illustrating his point by waving the knife in the air as though he were engaged in swordplay.

Secure in his logic, Arnaud starts slicing the pointy ends off of several lemons, eventually shaving off small bits from each piece to create more-or-less square lemons as building blocks to create his tower.

In the studio, there is dissent about whether or not Arnaud’s interpretation is valid. Antoine brings up the following dictionary definition for ‘maniement’ (which actually means ‘handle’ or ‘manipulate’, two of the interpretations of the verb used in the task): ‘To have in hand or between the hands, while moving or wiggling’.

Alex points out that Arnaud did not always move the knife while it was in his hand, so Louis asks Antoine to replay Arnaud’s attempt so they can check if the knife was always moving. It is ultimately determined that by the time Arnaud had put down the knife at the end of what he had considered to be his first wield, he had already used all five wields.

Instead of disqualifying Arnaud, Louis awards him joint fourth place, as he appreciated the thinking and the effort that went into creating the tower.


Points

Contestant Points Notes
Bianca Gervais 5
Richardson Zéphir 4
Alex Perron 3
Arnaud Soly 2
Virginie Fortin 2


Similar tasks

Tags

lemons · bowls · towers · knife · knives · cutting boards · building · constructing · balancing · cutting · wielding · making · tallest · only · maximum